Inside the Democratic Party's leadership crisis: 'It's not enough just to complain'

Massachusetts Congressman Seth Moulton ripped into his own party this week, declaring that Democrats have surrendered the role of leadership and become little more than a reactive force against Donald Trump—a strategy he says is a guaranteed loser.

"It's not enough just to get on TV and complain. You got to give people a vision of the future," Moulton told John Avalon on the Bulwark's "How to Fix It" podcast. "I think that's something that Democrats especially need to do right now."

Speaking as he campaigns for U.S. Senate against 80-year-old incumbent Ed Markey, Moulton hammered his party for what he called reflexive opposition masquerading as strategy. The problem, he argued, starts at the top: a gerontocracy in Congress completely unequipped to lead on the issues that will define the next generation.

"I don't think people look at the gerontocracy in the Senate right now and say, okay, they're going to figure out AI," he said bluntly. "The running joke in the Senate is that half the Senate can't even spell AI."

But Moulton's indictment went much deeper. He torched the Trump administration's Iran war as a catastrophic strategic disaster that has weakened America while strengthening adversaries. The Pentagon has burned through missile inventories at precisely the moment it should be building capacity to deter China. Meanwhile, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's purge of military leadership during wartime has created a climate of fear that destroys military excellence.

"That is a hallmark of the Soviet military. That's a hallmark of the Chinese Communist Party," Moulton said of Hegseth's loyalty purges. "Ideological loyalty. It's the opposite of that that has always made America the best country on Earth and made our military far and away the best military on Earth."

When pressed on Democratic policy alternatives, Moulton laid out a sweeping domestic agenda. Housing, healthcare, and education should be declared non-negotiable human rights, he argued. Universal pre-K would solve multiple crises at once: it improves outcomes, cuts crime decades later, and unlocks workforce participation for working parents.

On healthcare, he proposed a public option that would offer genuine competition to private insurers without forcing anyone off their current plans. "It's essentially like Medicare for all who want it," he explained.

Perhaps his most passionate pitch centered on high-speed rail as an economic justice issue. Morocco—with one-third of Massachusetts's GDP—has built trains reaching nearly 200 mph. Yet Boston to Springfield remains slower by train than by car. Building connected rail corridors across America would revitalize dying Rust Belt cities while making housing affordable by expanding where people can live and work.

But Moulton saved his harshest criticism for his party's complete abandonment of immigration policy. Democrats can describe what Republicans are doing but cannot articulate their own position on the issue that cost them the 2024 election.

"In town halls across Massachusetts, I ask everyone in the room: how many of you are opposed to Trump's immigration enforcement? Every hand goes up," Moulton said. "Then I say: how many of you Democrats can describe to me what Democrats' immigration policy is? Not a single hand."

His alternative is straightforward: prosecute ICE for illegal actions, create a system that incentivizes legal immigration over border crossing, and provide pathways to citizenship for longtime residents and DACA recipients.

"That's called leadership," Moulton concluded. "And I think that when Democrats lead, Democrats win."

• george conway
• noam chomsky
• civil war
• Kayleigh mcenany
• Melania trump
• drudge report
• paul krugman
• Lindsey graham
• Lincoln project
• al franken bill maher
• People of praise
• Ivanka trump
• eric trump